After this year’s State of Canada’s Cities Summit, which I will write more about soon, I joined about twenty people in the back room of Brigid’s Well, a basement pub beneath an old church in Ottawa. Iain Montgomery, who hosts the Challenger Cities podcast and Substack, led a conversation about what Ottawa should become and what plan would get it there.
Most of what was said about Ottawa applies to Toronto. Residents don’t know to ask for something they have never experienced. A city, therefore, learns more from trying an idea at small scale and letting people learn from the result than from asking them to dream up what they want.
Who answers the question
Ottawa became a single city in 2001, when the province merged eleven municipalities and their regional government. The city now includes the downtown, suburbs such as Kanata and Orléans, and a large rural area. People in the room said many suburban residents describe themselves as being from Kanata, not from Ottawa.
Iain points out that Toronto asks the same question of Scarborough, and that a person can be from Brooklyn and from New York without having to choose. One suggestion on the night was to present the Greenbelt, which separates the older city from the suburbs beyond it, as a shared asset that connects them. Iain’s own proposal is to treat Ottawa as a city of villages, where belonging to a part shouldn’t mean opting out of the whole.
Toronto has been one city since 1998, and its neighbourhood identities are a strength. The difficulty comes when decisions with citywide effects are made one ward at a time, which I wrote about in Big Ideas for Toronto That Cost Almost Nothing. A resident can identify with Scarborough and still expect those decisions to be made for the whole city.
An election does not settle the question. On October 26, Toronto re-elected Olivia Chow with 54 percent of the vote on 46 percent turnout, and Ottawa re-elected Mark Sutcliffe and 21 sitting councillors. Those votes chose who governs for the next four year, not what kind of city they want, given that none of the candidates offered a clear or bold vision for their respective city’s future.
Ottawa also has two bodies in charge of public space. The City manages streets and transit. The National Capital Commission, a federal Crown corporation, owns more than 11 percent of the land in the capital region, including the Greenbelt and the Rideau Canal Skateway. Iain notes that two owners do not have to mean conflict, but people in the room were unsure which body could approve an idea. Attendees at his Toronto salon earlier this year asked the same thing about where to take a proposal.
Who takes part
The usual way to ask residents is public consultation. Several people in the room observed that these meetings draw the same participants, often older residents with strong views and free evenings, while most residents never attend. I see a version of this in my own neighbourhood. The people who attend our association’s meetings and send comments are a small share of the people who live in the area.
Three political scientists at Boston University reviewed the minutes of planning and zoning meetings about housing in 97 Massachusetts cities and towns. Participants were more likely than other residents to be older, male, longtime residents and homeowners. Almost two-thirds of them spoke against the housing being proposed. The data is from Massachusetts, and it is consistent with what people in the Ottawa room described.
Toronto has tested a different design. In 2015, City Planning mailed invitations to 12,000 randomly chosen households to form the Toronto Planning Review Panel. More than 500 people volunteered, and 28 were chosen by civic lottery, a random draw balanced so that the group matched the city’s demographics, including its share of owners and renters. Members served for two years and advised planning staff on major initiatives. A panel selected this way includes people who would not come to an evening meeting.
Knowing what is missing
A representative group still chooses among options it can picture. The room spent some time on whether people can be content in a city that visitors consider poorly designed. They can, and their contentment counts for more than a visitor’s opinion. The harder question was whether residents can ask for something they have never used.
Iain has written about this using the Kano model, a product design framework that sorts features by their effect on satisfaction. Basics are noticed only when they fail. Performance features raise satisfaction steadily as they improve. The third group, which he calls delighters, are features nobody requested because nobody knew they were possible.
He lists The Bentway as a Toronto example. The space under the Gardiner Expressway became a public trail after Judy and Wil Matthews donated $25 million to the city in 2015, having developed the idea with the urban designer Ken Greenberg. Its skating trail opened in January 2018. It is unlikely that a consultation would have produced a request for a skating trail under an expressway.
Trying it first
Ottawa’s best-known public space began as a trial. In December 1970 the Ottawa Journal wrote that the idea of skating on the Rideau Canal was being lost because nobody had the will to make it work. The next month Douglas Fullerton, the new chair of the National Capital Commission, had a crew clear a short section of ice near the National Arts Centre with brooms and shovels. Thousands of people came on the opening weekend. The track was extended about 5 kilometres to Dow’s Lake that winter, and the Skateway now runs 7.8 kilometres.
The test cost little, and it could have ended after one winter if nobody had come.
The King Street transit pilot in Toronto followed the same pattern. It began in November 2017 as a one-year trial with results published monthly, and council made it permanent in April 2019 by a vote of 22 to 3. Gil Peñalosa made the general case on Iain’s podcast. Trials are cheap and reversible, and one that works should be extended across the city.
Iain’s main observation from Ottawa adds a condition. People there do try new things, he writes, but turnout is often thin, and a half-empty room is taken as proof that the idea failed. A trial therefore needs a fixed period and a measure agreed at the start, as King Street had. It also needs residents to take part.
He describes how the work divides. Ottawa has a nightlife commissioner, and someone in that role can fix licensing, bring venues together and make the case to council. Filling a venue on a February night is up to residents and businesses. This matches my own view of government, which is that it does the most good when it removes barriers and lets residents, businesses and community groups do the rest.
The trade-off
Trying first and judging afterward gives less weight to the residents who attend consultations now. Consultation has value because it catches bad proposals. In Saving Toronto, Thirty Years Later I argued for keeping the debate over what should be permitted while limiting delay on individual projects that already meet the rules.
The same division applies here. Trials suit changes that can be reversed, such as a street layout, a seasonal closure or a permit for a temporary use. A building cannot be removed after a year, so the rules for buildings still need full debate in advance.
Within those limits, a residents association can argue about the measure of success before a trial begins and then accept the result. That is a smaller role than many associations have now, and I think it is the right one.
What next?
Toronto’s new council can run more time-limited trials, with the measure and the decision date stated at the start, and extend the ones that meet the measure. Wider use of civic lottery panels would mean the people assessing a trial reflect the city. Residents also need to know who approves a proposal for a street, a park or an event.
Iain’s advice to Ottawa residents applies in Toronto as well. Anyone can book a room, invite twenty people and try an idea, then ask for help to make it bigger. An official who receives experiments from residents has evidence to point to when bringing a motion to council.
Council sets the rules, runs the trials and decides how results are measured. Whether a trial succeeds also depends on residents turning up for it, and that includes residents associations. I’ve been thinking a lot about the role of residents associations lately; stay tuned, more to come on that soon.


Thanks for your posts Dan. I agree that people don't know what they are missing and small trials are important. I think the same of sound, yet the first few months of the pandemic gave us a glimpse of what happens when we remove the hum of vehicles. We don't need to go to those extremes today but there was a brief window of "oh I can sleep with the window open/ hear birds / hear people / enjoy my balcony". That changed how people perceive sound, with some becoming aware of their sensitivities or preferences and for the first time, feeling comfort and safety.
I think we need to have some more trials and measure the sound levels of pedestrainized areas, before and after vehicles have been restricted... and also ask those qualitative questions.. how did you sleep? How did you feel? What changed?
Once we find out how much better we feel with "Sounds That Favour Us" there won't be going back. The question is how can we get there first? Trials.